Rubrics
Every graded component in this course is scored against a published rubric. The rubric you are shown before you do the work is the one your work is graded against.
The rubrics
| Rubric | Applies to | Scored by |
|---|---|---|
| Discussion | Contributions to case discussions, reading discussions, and discussions with visiting guests | Instructor |
| Design Sprint Project | The Fall term final design presentation | Instructor |
| Business Model Presentation | The Winter term final presentation | Instructor (and invited judges) |
Three components have no rubric because they are graded pass/fail on submission or delivery: self-reflections (submit something that answers the questions), peer assessments (submit them, on time — you are not graded on how generously or harshly you rate people), and weekly project update presentations (deliver an update showing progress since last week, including a response to feedback). What your teammates say in their peer assessments does not score you directly; it feeds the proportion-of-work backstop described in the syllabus.
How grading works
All rubrics are anchored on letter grades. Each dimension of each rubric is marked as a letter on the Dalhousie grade scale, not as a number out of five. A letter is a more intuitive statement of how a piece of work went than a number is, and it means you can read your mark without translating it.
To compute a grade, each letter converts to the top of its percentage range:
| A+ | A | A- | B+ | B | B- | C+ | C | C- | D |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 100 | 89 | 84 | 79 | 76 | 72 | 69 | 64 | 59 | 54 |
Your grade for a component is the mean of those values across the rubric’s dimensions — and, for discussions, across the classes in which a discussion was graded.
This mapping has a property worth knowing: if you are marked the same letter everywhere, your grade for the component is that letter. Marked B on every dimension, you get 76% — a B. Marked A- throughout, you get 84% — an A-. Mixed marks land between the letters they fall between, as you would expect.
Zero
A zero is not a letter grade. It is what you receive when there is nothing to grade:
- Present but did not contribute to a discussion — no letter is recorded for you that class, and it counts as zero.
- Absent without an approved Student Declaration of Absence — zero for anything graded in that class.
- Absent with an approved SDA — that class is excluded from your mean rather than scored zero, so an excused absence neither helps nor hurts you.
A note on polish
These rubrics were revised for 2026 on the principle that what AI makes free stops earning points. Visual polish, deck consistency, and prototype fidelity are no longer scored anywhere. What is scored is whether the work does a job: whether a slide carries the point it is there to make, whether evidence is real and specific, whether you can defend a claim when questioned. A beautiful deck that does not carry the argument scores below a plain one that does. See the Artificial Intelligence section of the syllabus.
The rubrics used through 2025-26, in their original numeric form, are kept as a deprecated archive for reference. They are no longer in use.