Skip to the content.
Home | Syllabus | Grading | Rubrics | Schedule | Resources

Discussion Rubric

Much of this course is discussion, and this one rubric covers all of it: case discussions, discussions of assigned readings that are not cases, and the discussions that follow a guest’s visit. In every one of them, your contribution to that class is marked as one letter grade, recorded during the class.

There are no separate sub-scores. Preparation, analysis, and how you participate all feed a single judgement, because they are not really separable in a live discussion. Someone who has not read the material cannot analyze it; someone who monopolizes the floor is not participating well no matter how good the content is.

Scoring

Find the band that describes your contribution, then the specific letter within it.

Grade What this looks like
A+ Depth of preparation or attention is unmistakable. Your contribution synthesizes the material with other readings, earlier classes, or knowledge from outside the course, and takes the discussion somewhere it had not gone. You build on what classmates have said rather than restarting the conversation.
A / A- You have clearly engaged with the material and thought about it. Your contribution connects across parts of it, or connects it to other course material or outside information. You build on others’ points.
B+ / B / B- You have done the reading, or listened closely, and offer a sensible interpretation grounded in the material. At least one substantive, relevant contribution that moves the discussion along.
C+ / C / C- You know roughly what the material says, likely from skimming rather than reading closely. Your contribution shows basic understanding but adds little analysis.
D You contribute, but off-topic, or without connecting to the material in a sensible way, or with no evidence of having engaged with it.
(no mark) Present, but did not contribute. This is a zero for the class, not a D.

Air time is a cap, not a dimension. Dominating the discussion — repeatedly speaking without leaving room for others, interrupting, or jumping in without being called on — caps your mark at C for that class, however strong the content. Air time is finite, and a discussion in which four people speak is worth more than one in which one person performs. Equally, holding back so far that you never speak is not modesty; it is a zero.

What preparation means in each kind of discussion

The bands above are the same in all three settings. What differs is what you are expected to arrive having done.

Case discussions. Read the case closely before class. The strongest contributions connect parts of the case to each other, and connect the case to concepts from earlier classes.

Reading discussions. Same expectation, applied to whatever was assigned in that class’s Pre-Class Assignment. A reading is usually making an argument; a good contribution engages with the argument, not only with the summary.

Guest discussions. There is normally nothing to prepare — guests do not usually supply material in advance — so what is scored is entirely what you do with what you hear in the room. A strong question is one that could only have been asked by someone paying close attention, and that connects what the guest said to the course or to something outside it.

Guest classes are graded only if the instructor is present. Where a guest presents in the instructor’s absence, that class is not graded and is excluded from your mean entirely. The insight a guest brings is often exactly what improves your project work, which is graded.

How this becomes a grade

Each letter converts to the top of its percentage range:

A+ A A- B+ B B- C+ C C- D
100 89 84 79 76 72 69 64 59 54

Your grade for the Case/Guest Discussions component (30% of the term) is the mean of these values across every class in which a discussion was graded, whatever kind of discussion it was. Because each letter maps to the top of its range, consistently earning a given letter yields exactly that letter as your component grade.

A class you miss with an approved SDA is excluded from the mean. A class you miss without one counts as zero.

What this rubric does not measure

Whether you used AI to prepare is not a criterion here and never will be. Reading a case or an article with an AI tool, arguing with it about the material, or having it quiz you beforehand are all permitted and sometimes a good idea — but note that uploading Harvard course pack material to an AI platform breaches the licence. What is scored is what you say in the room, in real time, in response to what other people say. No tool can do that for you. See the Artificial Intelligence section of the syllabus.