Skip to the content.
Home | Syllabus | Grading | Rubrics | Schedule | Resources

Business Model Presentation Rubric

This is used to grade the final presentation in Winter term (50% of the term grade), in which each team describes the business model they arrived at and the lessons they learned getting there.

This is not necessarily a pitch. Not every effort results in a viable business model, and none of the marks below depend on yours being viable. What is graded is how deeply and thoroughly you pursued the model, how well you can defend it on evidence, and how honestly you reflect on the learning along the way. A team that ran a rigorous process and concluded the idea does not work can score at the top of this rubric.

Two dimensions are scored individually and the rest are scored for the team as a whole. Individual team members can still receive a higher or lower grade than their teammates in exceptional circumstances, and through the proportion-of-work mechanism described in the syllabus.

Dimensions

  1. Verbal Communication — scored individually
  2. Visual Presentation — scored as a team
  3. Team Cohesion — scored as a team
  4. Business Model Quality — scored as a team
  5. Lessons Learned — scored individually

Scoring

Each dimension is marked as a letter grade on the Dalhousie scale. Find the band that describes the work, then the specific letter within it. Letters convert to the top of their percentage range:

A+ A A- B+ B B- C+ C C- D
100 89 84 79 76 72 69 64 59 54

Your grade for the presentation is the mean of the five dimension values. Because each letter maps to the top of its range, a presentation marked the same letter on every dimension earns exactly that letter.

This presentation is delivered publicly and may be scored by invited judges as well as the instructor. Where judges score, their marks are averaged with the instructor’s.

Verbal Communication

Scored individually.

Grade Criteria
A+ Speech is exceptionally clear and easy to understand (within reasonable constraints, such as accent or physical limitations). Intonation is particularly dynamic without seeming excessive or inappropriate to the topic and audience. Points are presented in logical order and are exceptionally easy to follow.
A / A- Speech is clear and easy to understand (within reasonable constraints, such as accent or physical limitations). Intonation is appropriately dynamic. Points are presented in logical order and are easy to follow.
B+ / B / B- Speech is mostly clear and easy to understand (within reasonable constraints, such as accent or physical limitations). Intonation is somewhat dynamic. Points are presented in generally logical order and are mostly easy to follow.
C+ / C / C- Speech is frequently unclear and/or hard to understand (within reasonable constraints, such as accent or physical limitations). Intonation is quite flat. Points are hard to follow and logical flow is limited.
D Speech is mostly unclear and/or hard to understand (within reasonable constraints, such as accent or physical limitations). Intonation is very flat/monotone. Points are hard to follow and logical flow is lacking.

Visual Presentation

Scored as a team.

Grade Criteria
A+ Every slide carries the point being made, and is the right visual for that point. Evidence shown is real, specific, and sourced. Text is used sparingly, relying on narration for detail. Graphics are exceptionally clear and could not be removed without losing the argument. Nothing is present for decoration. No errors.
A / A- Nearly every slide carries the point being made and is well chosen for it. Evidence shown is real and specific. Text is used sparingly, relying on narration for detail. Graphics are clear and support the argument. Little is present for decoration. No errors.
B+ / B / B- Most slides carry the point being made, though some are generic or better suited to a different claim. Evidence is mostly specific, but some assertions are unsupported. Text is somewhat over-used. Graphics are generally relevant but may require explanation. Errors are minimal.
C+ / C / C- Slides often do not carry the point being made — they restate the topic rather than advancing the argument. Evidence is vague, generic, or asserted without support. Text is over-used, with slides requiring extensive reading that distracts from the narration. Graphics are decorative, hard to interpret, or not clearly connected to the claims. A few errors are present.
D Slides do not carry the argument. Content is generic and could belong to almost any project. Claims are unsupported. Text is over-used and read aloud. Graphics are decorative, unclear, or irrelevant. Many errors are present.

Note on polish: visual polish is no longer scored. AI tools make a professional-looking deck essentially free, so appearance carries little information about your work. What is scored is whether each slide does a job — whether it carries the point, shows real evidence, and is the right visual for the claim. A beautiful deck that does not carry the argument scores below a plain one that does.

Team Cohesion

Scored as a team.

Grade Criteria
A+ Team demonstrates exceptional cohesiveness and cooperation. Members show respect and work off of each other. Team has clearly rehearsed extensively together. Team evidences clear division of labour and leverages individuals’ strengths. Roles and contributions of each team member to the work and presentation are clear.
A / A- Team demonstrates high cohesiveness and cooperation. Members show respect and work off of each other. Team has clearly rehearsed together. Team evidences clear division of labour and leverages individuals’ strengths. Roles and contributions of each team member to the work and presentation are clear.
B+ / B / B- Team demonstrates some cohesiveness and cooperation. Members show respect and work off of each other, at least some of the time. Evidence of team rehearsal is weak. Team evidences some division of labour. Roles and contributions of each team member to the work and presentation are not entirely clear.
C+ / C / C- Team demonstrates limited cohesiveness and cooperation. Limited evidence of respect for other team members, or cooperation. Team members appear to have prepared individually with little to no coordination. Team evidences some division of labour. Roles and contributions of each team member to the work and presentation are not clear.
D Team demonstrates poor cohesiveness and cooperation. Limited evidence of respect for other team members, or cooperation. Team members appear to have prepared individually (or not at all) with little to no coordination. Unclear division of labour. Roles and contributions of each team member to the work and presentation are not clear.

Business Model Quality

Scored as a team.

Grade Criteria
A+ Demonstrates exceptionally deep understanding of each cell of the Business Model Canvas, and how the cells relate to each other. Contents are framed as hypotheses or as evidence, as appropriate, and each is clearly linked to a particular customer segment. An exceptional degree of customer discovery is evident and clearly documented. The team can explain the contents of every cell, present the evidence behind them, and defend them well on evidence and logic. Shows exceptional evidence of having integrated the assigned videos and readings into the model.
A / A- Demonstrates deep understanding of each cell of the canvas, and how the cells relate to each other. Contents are framed as hypotheses or as evidence, as appropriate, and each is clearly linked to a particular customer segment. The expected degree of customer discovery is evident and clearly documented. The team can explain the contents of every cell, present evidence, and defend them on evidence and logic. Shows evidence of having integrated the assigned videos and readings.
B+ / B / B- Demonstrates some understanding of each cell, and how the cells relate. Contents are appropriate to the cells they sit in, and hypotheses can be distinguished from evidence. Statements can be linked to a particular customer segment. The extent of customer discovery is unclear or lower than expected. The team can explain the contents, but may have limited supporting evidence and/or be unable to defend them convincingly. Shows limited evidence of having integrated the assigned videos and readings.
C+ / C / C- Demonstrates limited understanding of each cell, and how the cells relate. Contents are in roughly the right cells, but hypotheses and evidence are not clearly distinguished. Only some statements can be linked to a customer segment. The extent of customer discovery is unclear or well below expectations. Limited ability to explain or defend the contents.
D Demonstrates limited understanding of each cell, and how the cells relate. Contents are not appropriate to the cells they sit in. Hypotheses and evidence are not distinguished. Few statements can be linked to a customer segment. Customer discovery is unclear or very far below expectations. Little to no ability to explain or defend the contents. Shows little or no evidence of having integrated the assigned videos and readings, and/or uses them inappropriately.

Lessons Learned

Scored individually.

Grade Criteria
A+ Exceptional articulation of lessons learned, spanning the entire course (both terms). Evidence backs up statements of learning. Exceptional examples are provided. Unexpected but powerful connections across topics of the course and outside material are presented.
A / A- Clear articulation of lessons learned, spanning most of the course (both terms). Evidence generally backs up statements of learning. Examples are provided. Connections across topics of the course and outside material are presented.
B+ / B / B- Good articulation of lessons learned, spanning much of the course (including topics from both terms). Some evidence backs up statements of learning. Some examples are provided. Connections across topics of the course and outside material are limited.
C+ / C / C- Adequate articulation of lessons learned, spanning multiple course topics. Limited evidence backs up statements of learning. Few examples are provided. Connections across topics of the course and outside material are lacking.
D Poor articulation of lessons learned, covering few course topics. Evidence is not presented to support statements of learning. Examples are not provided. Connections across topics of the course and outside material are absent.