Skip to the content.
Home |
Syllabus |
Grading |
Rubrics |
Schedule |
Resources
Term 1, Class 5
Critiques and Future of Design Thinking
Learning Objectives
- Understand current trends in design and design thinking
- Critique the conventional approach to design thinking
- Judge the quality of AI-generated design work, and identify what it reliably gets wrong about real people
- Explain why the scarce skill in an AI-saturated process is judgement, not generation
Pre-Class Assignment
Class Outline
- Warm-up: Mock-Ups game (15 min)
- Tearing apart AI design work (30 min) — in teams of 3 (six teams), all working from the same material
- Every team gets the same set of AI-generated design artefacts for one problem domain: personas, a problem statement, a list of “customer pains”, and a proposed solution. Teams may generate their own with any tool they prefer, or work from the set I bring — nobody is required to operate an AI tool. The skill being built here is the critique, not the generation.
- Analysis (18 min). Working against what you actually know about real people, identify: what is plausible but unverifiable; what is generic enough to describe almost anybody; what is stated confidently and is probably false; and what a real interview would have surfaced that this did not.
- Report-back (12 min). Each team names, in 90 seconds, the single most dangerous thing in the set — the claim a team would be most likely to build on and most likely to regret. Teams 4, 5, and 6 must add something not yet said.
- Where several teams independently flag the same thing, that convergence is the finding: it shows what these tools get wrong reliably, not by accident.
- Discussion of assigned readings (25 min)
- Blank’s finding that his teams could generate more product than they could validate, and started to treat the product as the truth
- Why “great ideas are getting harder to find” if generation is now free — what is the actual bottleneck?
- Where the standard critiques of design thinking land now that prototyping is cheap